Risks of technical mastery- and the slippery slope of price competition
Posted on October 31st, 2008Professional firms fall into two camps: the ones that compete with themselves and the ones that compete to meet client needs.
What is the focus of your professional firm?
A lot of people answer the question by saying, ”We are a top-tier firm”, “We are the top consultants”, “We are the best architects”, “We are the best systems integrators”.
Others focus on the message and delivery of “We are committed to meeting client needs.”
Which one rides out an economic down-turn better?
Here is an article from Business Week the other week about Top-Tier law firms in crisis.
I saw it in 1987. I saw it in 2001. We’re seeing it again.
Let’s first acknowledge we are not just talking about law firms. They do tend to be more insular and less business minded, like any technocracy. But the pitfalls of price sensitivity happens in consultancies and other services businesses in similar ways.
1. Technical Mastery: When a firm tries to define itself as blue chip… “We are the ‘premier law firm’, we hire only the brightest legal minds”… they are really saying “Our strategy is technical excellence. We hope our clients like it because that is what we charge the big bucks for”.
2. “Add Business Value”: When a firm says “We are great lawyers and we are committed to bringing specific and demonstrable value to our business clients” what they are saying is that they are commited to: a) Relevance - that is, what does the client need in this situation? b) Tailoring - or how do we translate our technical mastery into their context and needs? If we do not enable their business, we have not done our job and finally c) Results - specifically delivering value to the client in their terms.
Good business solutions are not always the “best” antiseptic solutions from the lab (that is - technically perfect). Technocrats don’t value “dirty” but effective solutions. Business clients do.
Who has the strongest play right now?
The Technical Mastery Play: Strong enough during good markets but subject to price compression when the chips are down. Deal flow goes down, excess capacity among competitors goes up and prices get trashed. Technique loses with increased emphasis on business results. Voila - you are now a commodity!
The “Add Business Value” Play: No one is immune to intense economic buffering. Creating relationships, loyalty, consistent value and a firm, confident hand in a crisis keeps a much more centered path in a crisis.
How do you want to play?



